Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Murderers and Catcher in the Rye

After reading the first 26 pages of Catcher in the Rye, I thought that the book was a pretty easy read and not too boring. Some things, however, made me think that there was something a little odd about this book. Before we started reading, Mr. Kunkle showed us that slideshow previewing J.D. Salinger and Catcher in the Rye. In the slideshow it told about how it was one of the most banned books in American history. It also told about how many murderers and a few famous assassins were obsessed with this book. The entire time I was reading the first three chapters, all I could think about was looking for hints and clues as to why these people were so obsessed with it. I found a few discrete, disturbing lines in the book. One I even annotated in the side writing "serial killer?" This was when Ackley was asking Holden about his new hat he got. Ackley says it looks like a deer-hunting hat or something. Holden casually replies that it is a people-hunting hat. He thinks nothing of this but I thought it was quite odd to say something like that. Another thing I noted was that the mood of the story is very negative and bitter. Holden also has a very carefree and "doesn't really care" type of attitude. I don't really know a lot about serial killers and what they think but I feel like they would have a similar attitude as Holden. Maybe the reason they are obsessed with the book is because they look up to Holden and can relate to how he thinks.

5 comments:

  1. Alissa, that was really good!
    When I was reading about the people-hunting hat, I thought the exact same thing. And I also agree that with his personality of being negative all the time, I can see why serial killers enjoy this book so much. Ahh!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Liss,
    I agree with you about how down and negative Holden was! How strange for the main character of a book! I don't quite understand how a serial killer would look up to Holden though. Any insights?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with you too!
    Holden is definately going to turn into a phscyo killer!
    He's always talking about being depressed, sad, and lonely. He's also seems to have had a rough childhood and I think he may be mentally messed up...
    But we'll find out!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that Holden may be a serial killer.
    Because Holden is telling the story in past tense, maybe he has already killed the people he has met. Maybe he calls Ackley, Old Ackley because he has already murdered Ackley. He wishes that he should have done this or should have done that to prevent what he has done in the present.

    ReplyDelete
  5. IK!!! This book is very odd and creeperish
    but none the less i think that people make their own decisions to be a serial killer. This book does hint at some key points in it though



    CHURN!!!

    ReplyDelete