Sunday, November 22, 2009

Views up until chapter 21 for Catcher!

In my previous post, I already expressed how weird and psycho Holden is. I find myself writing "creepy", "wierdo", and "crazy" often in the margins of my book. A lot of things he does just don't make sense to me. One thing that really weirded me out in the reading we had to do for Monday was the part where he agreed to paying for a prostitute to come up to his room. His behavior with the prostitute was very strange to me. He agreed to it in the first place which was odd, then kept asking her to talk with him. Another thing that REALLY made me question Holden's sanity this reading was his asking Sally to run away with him north and marry him. They weren't even dating and randomly during the date he just decided to spring this on her. I was confused as to why he would say such a thing. You could tell that Sally was very weirded out by this. When reading this I jotted down in the margin that Holden doesn't think before he speaks. I think he is mentally crazy and any weird thought that comes to his mind he tells to whomever he is with. After he said this, Sally got very "sore" (haha) and the date abruptly ended shortly after when Holden called her a "pain in the ass." That's another thing that I thought was very strange about their date. Bofore she arrived to the theatre, he was talking about how he wasn't really looking forward to the date. When she got there, he said she looked very beautiful and actually told her that he loved her in the taxi. Then, after the theatre when she was talking to her "obnoxious rich friend" he said that he hated her. THEN, he asks her to run away with him and marry her. And then the date ends with him hating her again. I think Holden is crazy.

2 comments:

  1. I think if I were in Sally's position, I'd feel pretty disturbed too. I agree with you one hundred percent that Holden is crazy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Holden is definitly bipolar! This book is all about extremes, either Holden is on some weird crazy high or super depressed. When Holden is walking back to the hotel and talking to his dead brother to keep from disappearing as he crosses the street...that is definitly a fantastic example of how insane he really is. I wonder if at the end of the book, if Holden is in the hospital/clinic because of mental issues or because of tb or something of the sort.

    ReplyDelete